GMB: Ranvir Singh recalls ‘smacking’ her child

When you subscribe we will use the information you provide to send you these newsletters. Sometimes they’ll include recommendations for other related newsletters or services we offer. Our Privacy Notice explains more about how we use your data, and your rights. You can unsubscribe at any time.

The calls come after a study found physical punishment actually leads to kids being more aggressive and anti-social. However, University College London discovered nearly two thirds (63%) of children across the world are regularly subjected to physical punishment by their caregivers. 

Express readers on Facebook commented that they’re largely supportive of physical punishment and believe it shouldn’t be made illegal, in line with recent changes in Wales and Scotland.

Writing on Facebook, many parents argued this approach has helped their development as children and that of their own kids.

One man wrote: “Absolute garbage: we are now suffering from the lack of discipline, where children know they can’t be touched, so take no notice when being asked to stop misbehaving.”

Another Facebook user shared: “The generations that were smacked mostly have respect and manners and are not self-entitled who believe the whole world owes them a favour.”

One mum posted: “A good smack when deserved speaks a thousand words. You won’t need telling twice.

If the law changes, it will stop any physical punishment of any kind in any setting, including schools.

But the Express Facebook community argued it was most effective in schools when they grew up because it ensured any bad behaviour was stopped from the offset.

One woman wrote: “I use to get smacked, never did me any harm. In fact I knew if I did the same thing twice, I knew what I got so made you stop in your tracks. I also use to get the cane at school but I’m still here.”

Another social media user shared: “Utter rubbish. They banned the cane in schools and now teachers have no real control. 

“Children need discipline both at home and in school and if that means a smack or cane so be it.”

The minority of readers, however, agree smacking should be banned in England.

They alluded to an argument made by the researchers that highlights how harmful it can be to some children.

One man wrote: “I’m willing to bet more children who regularly get hit by their parents are more eager to go around being violent and destructive than those children who are taught to resolve issues using words.”

Another Facebook user posted: “I was never hit, I never hit my kids. We are all respectful members of society.”

A third comment reads: “Respect works both ways, if you spend time engaging with them then talking to them is all that’s needed.”

Source: Read Full Article